Car Rentals in Sanibel Island. Search for Rental Cars on momondo

Are you looking for cheap car rental deals in Sanibel Island? Search right here!

15 May — 22 May

Driver's age:

26-65Other

Deals from rental companies in 70,000+ locations.

Save money when you book cars with momondo

Best deals on cars

See deals from rental companies in 70,000+ locations.

Price transparency

See the total cost up front so there are no surprises.

Book with flexibility

Find cars with free cancellation and enhanced cleaning.

Price Alerts

Not ready to book? Create a price alert to track prices.

Search car deals

Rental cars insight and trends in Sanibel Island

Useful insights to help you book the perfect rental car in Sanibel Island

What is the best rental car company in Sanibel Island?

Consider renting a car from Hertz, which is currently the best rental agency in Sanibel Island, according to our users. Hertz has 4 locations in some of Sanibel Island’s must-see cities, like Sanibel. With 60 reviews and an average rating of 6.3/10, Hertz is a favourite among travellers visiting Sanibel Island.

Sanibel Island car rental directory

All major car rental suppliers in Sanibel Island

Hertz

6.3

Okay

50 reviews•4 locations

Check prices

Overview

Recent reviews

10.0

Wonderful|Feb. 2023

While we had to catch a taxi from RSW to this office, the value and the service were well worth it!

2.0

Poor|Feb. 2023

didn't get to get my rental, flight showed up late and this Hertz was closing in 20 mins I tried to call multiple times to speak with a rep. but nobody picked up the phone. Lost my money and reservation

2.0

Poor|Feb. 2023

Agent lied about toll requirements, upsold pointless pass to the tune of $56 for 4 days.

6.0

Okay|Feb. 2023

We were to pickup a midsize at a satellite Hertz, not the airport. When we got there they had one car left, a Polestar EV, a Volvo product made in China, with 26% charge, and no way to charge it there. We basically had to take it, or we had to come back hours later with no guarantee we'd get a car. The instructions we were given about the EV were minimal. They did not have internet there for us to download the necessary APP to charge the car. We stopped at a Starbucks to get the APP. We then had to find a charging station. We had no experience with this, and went to one, only to find out it's a regular EV charger, and would take about 7 hours to charge the car. We couldn't wait that long. We then found a fast station, which took over 2 hours to charge. Bad way to start the vacation. We got to our destination about 3+ hours later than we should have. The next day we decided we would trade the car in for a gas car, as we didn't want to do the charging routine again. We went to the nearest airport and exchanged, easily, thankfully. That was an hour drive each way. Their lack of cars initially cost us about 6 hours that should not have happened.

4.0

Mediocre|Feb. 2023

Cost doubled when we were told that if we didn’t get the insurance, we would have to pay for the time that it took to fix the vehicle for repairs.. first time I ever agreed to insurance instead of using our own policy.

2.0

Poor|Dec. 2022

The car was not big enough. It was very dirty and had cigarette ashes in it. They told me I had to return it with 3/4 of a tank of gas. It only had a 1/4 tank when I picked it up! Also, the windshield washer fluid light was on because it was almost empty. Oh, not to mention that KAYAK told us the car was at the airport. It was NOT! It cost me $90.00 in Uber and taxi fees, to get to the car and get back to the airport. Never again through a third party! F-

1 out of 17

Enterprise Rent-A-Car

8.3

Very good

6 reviews•2 locations

Check prices

Overview

Budget

6.7

Okay

21 reviews•1 location

Check prices

Overview

Recent reviews

8.0

Very good|Jun. 2023

They told us to drop off the car ahead of their closing time so they could have time to clean it although they do have a drop key box. Technically, that time was ahead of what time we had to drop it off but we were ok doing that. Then, the day off, they called to make sure we were dropping off the car before it was due. We got the feeling we were being rushed so they could go home for the weekend. We’ve never had that happen before. Overall it is a convenient location and we rent a lot and will do it again.

2.0

Poor|Jul. 2022

I asked for an economy car. They were going to give me a suv without a choice. Very disappointed

8.0

Very good|Jul. 2022

It went well. My inky concern is when I dropped it off at Orlando airport I did not get a receipt. I entered into the drop off lot and was told I didn’t need to do anything else but leave the car there. Should I have gotten a receipt?

2.0

Poor|May 2022

I cancelled and they still charged me

2.0

Poor|Apr. 2022

I was notified TWO HOURS before my Pickup time that they had NO CARS!!! I was scheduled to be in Tampa at noon…. Had to uber ALL THE WAY to Ft Myers airport and stand in line for an hour to get my car! I was late….. and not happy AT ALL! The least they could have done was check me in “preferred” at the airport so i didnt have to stand in that long line

2.0

Poor|Apr. 2022

3 hour wait in line to pick up car, we got the last car. At least 30 people were turned away with reservations that had waited over 2 hrs in lone.

1 out of 7

Avis

5.6

Fair

4 reviews•1 location

Check prices

Overview

Dollar

1 location

Check prices

Thrifty

1 location

Check prices

Car rental in Sanibel Island

Learn everything there is to know about renting a car in Sanibel Island so you can be properly prepared for your next trip

When did momondo last update prices for cars in Sanibel Island?

Prices for cars in Sanibel Island are updated daily.

How old do you have to be to hire a car in Sanibel Island?

Among different countries, including Sanibel Island, the minimum age for drivers varies. In numerous EU countries, drivers must be 18 years old. To hire a car overseas, you'll generally need to be at least 21, and if you're under 25, a young driver surcharge may be imposed. It's recommended that you review the policy of the rental company you're considering before booking.

What documentation or ID do you need to rent a car in Sanibel Island?

To rent a car in Sanibel Island, all drivers must present a valid full driving license. If the license is written in a language other than the language of the country of rental, an International Driving Permit may be required to avoid the risk of potential fines. If you're renting a car abroad, you may also need to provide evidence of your return travel and accommodation information during your stay. We always recommend that you verify with the specific rental company you're booking with.

Why use momondo?

Why should I use momondo to book a car rental in Sanibel Island?

Booking a car rental in Sanibel Island via momondo could save you time and money. momondo provides you with a wide selection of options and cars as we search thousands of car rental websites and locations to enable you to make the best choice for your trip.

How does momondo help me find the best car rental deal in Sanibel Island?

By the use of filters, momondo makes finding a great car rental in Sanibel Island easier. Whether it is price, car type, amenities or policies, momondo allows you to refine your search with these and more filters to find the best deal for you.