Hotels in Sanibel Island

Looking at our users' ratings, the best hotels in Sanibel Island are Charming waterfront 2-bedroom condo on Sanibel Island! (10.0), located in Sanibel, Sanibel/Tarpon Tale Inn (9.7), located in Sanibel, and Sanibel/Lighthouse Resort And Club (9.7), located in Sanibel.

Sanibel Island Beach Resort is the most popular hotel in Sanibel Island, with 28% of all users who searched for hotels in Sanibel Island choosing to stay at Sanibel Island Beach Resort in the past 12 months. This hotel has a 8.0/10 rating from 1,901 reviews.

A hotel in Sanibel Island in November costs C$ 388 per night on average (for a double room). C$ 206 per night was the cheapest rate found in November for a double room, which was in Sanibel.

If you are travelling to Sanibel Island on a budget, plan to stay in Sanibel which boasts the lowest average hotel room cost in the country. Charging about 36% lower than the country’s average, hotel room rates in Sanibel are typically around C$ 338 per night.

While there are plenty of family hotels to choose from in Sanibel Island, the most popular among our users is Kona Kai Motel, which costs around C$ 318 per night on average. Sanibel Inn and Sundial Beach Resort & Spa are also great family hotels in Sanibel Island. Sanibel Inn has rooms for C$ 618 per night on average, while Sundial Beach Resort & Spa has rooms for C$ 587 per night.

If you’re looking for a couples getaway somewhere in Sanibel Island, then consider booking a room at Sanibel Inn (C$ 618 per night). Sundial Beach Resort & Spa, for C$ 587 per night on average, is another great couples hotel option in Sanibel Island. Our momondo users have also booked rooms at Tween Waters Island Resort & Spa quite often for a couples getaway in Sanibel Island. You can expect prices for Tween Waters Island Resort & Spa to be around C$ 422 per night.

As of November 2026, there are 2,209 operators available to choose from for hotels in Sanibel Island.

Prices for hotels in Sanibel Island are updated daily.